Heat Press vs Iron: Which One is Best for You?

A heat press costs a lot more than a simple iron does.  So it is only fair that you question whether you do in actual fact need a heat press machine for your heat transfer projects.

Iron vs Heat Press to Design Cap

In our post today we will have a heat press vs iron battle-off.

A successful heat transfer is all about having the right time, temperature and pressure. If you can get those three elements right, you will have a heat transfer that is perfectly adhered to your products of choice.

Get those three wrong and your transfer won’t stick to your surface very well and will most likely come off in the near-future.

Let’s look at the pros and cons of each and discuss which tool would be best for your specific needs.

 

Heat Press vs Irons

1. Irons

Irons are a great tool to have around a home. You can do so much more with an iron than simply iron clothes … in fact, I think my iron almost never gets used to iron clothes, it mostly gets a work out for craft purposes.

Irons are great because they are cheap, they are easy to store and easy to port around.  And most households already have one, so you don’t even have to purchase one.

If you do wish to work with an iron, we do recommend that you purchase decent iron-on vinyl as not all HTV are as easy to apply with an iron as others.

Here are some pros and cons of using an iron for iron-on transfers.

PROS:

  • It is portable and easy to store when not in use
  • You most likely already have one
  • They are affordable to purchase
  • They are fabulous for smaller designs
  • They heat up very quickly

CONS:

  • They have a small surface area for pressing, so impractical for larger designs.
  • You can’t control the temperature of the iron, whilst it might have different heat settings, you really have no idea how hot each setting really is. (Different types of vinyl require different types of heat)
  • It doesn’t have a digital timer built in, so you will need to watch the clock or count-down in your head whilst transferring your design.
  • The temperature can vary wildly throughout the surface of the plate. Some areas might be super hot whilst others are only warm. This means that you might end up with an iron-on that doesn’t stick as well as it could.
  • Steam irons have holes in the hot plate which will create an uneven pressure.

Verdict

Irons are an excellent choice for those who are beginners. They are also perfect if you know that you will only be doing heat transfers only occasionally (so it won’t make sense to invest in a heat press then). We definitely don’t recommend them for larger projects, but they can work great for smaller designs.

It also depends on what you are doing. For example, it is easier to work on T-shirts when you iron as the product is flat, but once you start working on items such as caps it can get trickier. Fortunately, you can buy attachments to help you heat press caps (and here is a great trick for how to heat press a hat with a normal press)

Don’t expect your design to last forever, as durability of the iron-on is much shorter in lifespan in comparison to those adhered with a heat press.  ecause you can’t control the temperature and pressure with an iron, you iron-on transfers are more likely to peel.

For more professional results, we highly recommend that you invest in a heat press. Also, check out our guide to the best HTV vinyl for info on which vinyl’s work well with an iron.

 

2. Heat Press

Heat Press Machine

A heat press is, of course, the professional tool for applying heat transfers.  Unlike irons that have been designed too well … iron wrinkles out of clothes, a heat press has specifically been designed to heat press designs.  They are fabulous for those of you who know that you will be working with iron-on on a regular basis.

Here are some pros and cons of using a heat press for iron-on transfers.

PROS

  • You have a large work surface
  • You can set and control the temperature of the machine
  • Temperature is distributed evenly along the plates
  • You can set a digital timer to get the timing spot-on
  • You can control the pressure applied to your iron-on
  • Results typically last longer in comparison to an iron

CONS

  • Heavy in design, so not really portable
  • Not as easy to store
  • More expensive than an iron

Verdict:

A heat press is a machine that has been designed specifically to adhere transfers to garments and products. As such you can control the exact temperature, adjust the pressure as well as set a timer to help you get a perfectly adhered designed.

The temperature of the plates are also evenly distributed and the larger work area (typically around 15″x15″) will allow you to work with larger designs.

Without a doubt, a heat press will help you to create more professional and longer-lasting heat transfers. We won’t even bother with the frustration and hassle of using an iron.  With an iron, it really comes down to good luck.  With a heat press, it is all an exact measured science to get the best results.

 

Fortunately, you can find some really affordable heat press machines these days.  Why not check out our heat press machine reviews to help you find the best starter heat press for you and your needs, you can find out more about how much a heat press costs here. You can also find some great buying tips of what to look for your heat press here.

Remember, you will also need some other tools in order to get started with t-shirt HTV transfers, you can find a list of the tools and supplies you need here.

Hope that helps you with your question.

Till next time,

Samantha xxx

Leave a Comment